Mabel stood beside him.

She paused, considering what to do next.

I recognized that expression immediately.

Her head tilted slightly to one side, just like a little bird.

Then she began singing.

Her voice was so soft that I had to turn my phone’s volume to its highest setting.

It was You Are My Sunshine.

My song.

The lullaby I sang to all four children every night.

I’d sung it while rocking them in the darkness, comforting Theo during difficult teething nights, helping Ivy settle after nighttime accidents, and reassuring June after bad dreams.

And now Mabel was singing that same familiar melody to her little brother.

Standing beside his playpen.

Using the gentle voice she’d heard from me so many times.

Theo stopped fussing.

He looked up at his sister.



Then he sat down and picked up the soft block.

Mabel continued singing.

She remembered the entire lullaby, including both verses, exactly as I usually sang it.

When she finished, she reached through the mesh side of the playpen and gently patted Theo’s head.

“Good boy, Theo,” she whispered. “Mommy’s in the shower. She’ll be right back. I’ll take care of you.”

I covered my mouth with my hand.

7:10 p.m.

Mabel returned to the couch.

She picked up Clover and resumed watching Bluey.

Brandon continued playing on his phone.

7:11 p.m.

Nothing changed.

7:12 p.m.

June stood up from the rug.

She held her bibba close as she started walking toward the kitchen.

But her foot caught the edge of the rug.

She stumbled forward.



Her forehead bumped against the corner of the coffee table.

Standing beside my kitchen sink at midnight, I gasped.

The recording captured a dull sound as she made contact with the furniture.

June sat on the floor, startled, holding one hand against her forehead.

For a moment, she seemed unsure what had happened.

Then she began crying.

Not an ordinary complaint or a frustrated whimper.

It was the unmistakable cry of a little child who had genuinely hurt herself.

It started softly and gradually grew louder.

“Waaaaah.”

Brandon didn’t look up.

Not even once.

His AirPods remained in his ears.

His thumbs continued moving, and the colorful light from his phone illuminated his face.

His three-year-old daughter had just stumbled into the coffee table only a few feet from where he was sitting.



Yet he appeared completely unaware.

Then Ivy looked up.

Ivy was sitting on the rug when she noticed her twin sister crying.

She immediately crawled toward June and wrapped her little arms around her.

“Nunu,” she murmured. “Nunu, nunu.”

Mabel had already climbed down from the couch.

She hurried over and knelt beside June.

“June,” she said. “June, let me see.”

Gently, she moved June’s hand away from her forehead.

She examined the spot with remarkable concentration, almost like a little doctor.

A reddish mark was visible, gradually becoming more noticeable and slightly swollen.

“You bumped your head,” Mabel explained. “On the table. It’s okay. It’s okay, Junie.”

June continued crying.

Mabel turned toward Brandon.

“Daddy!” she called loudly. “Daddy! June hit her head! She’s bleeding!”

There wasn’t actually any bleeding,

but Mabel was only four. To her, almost every injury seemed serious.

Brandon finally removed one AirPod.

He glanced toward the children.

June sat crying on the floor, Ivy had her arms around her, and Mabel knelt beside them.

He watched for perhaps two seconds.

“She’s fine,” he said. “Kids bump their heads. She’s fine.”

Then he replaced his AirPod.

His attention returned to his phone.

Mabel stared at him.

After a moment, she stood up and walked out of the camera’s view.

She was heading toward the kitchen.

7:13 p.m.

Mabel reappeared on the recording.

She was carrying something.

A bag of frozen peas.

She’d taken it from the freezer.

I always kept a bag of frozen peas in the freezer door for minor bumps and bruises.

I’d used it with all four children countless times, and Mabel had watched me do it again and again.

She must have walked into the kitchen, opened the freezer, and stretched onto her tiptoes to reach the shelf inside its door.

Then she’d carried the peas back.

She knelt beside June.

Very carefully, she placed the cold bag against her sister’s forehead.

Her movements were gentle and deliberate.

Exactly the way she’d seen me do it.

“Hold this,” she instructed. “It’s cold. It makes it feel better. That’s what Mommy does.”

June held the bag against her forehead.

Gradually, her crying stopped.

Mabel settled onto the rug beside her, with Ivy sitting on June’s opposite side.

There they were.

Three little girls in their pajamas, sitting together on the living room floor.

Mabel slipped an arm around June’s shoulders.