While standing at the sink, still feeling responsible for Brandon’s unpleasant evening, I remembered something.

Theo’s pacifier.

The green one.

His favorite.

He’d been using it when I left for my shower.

I remembered seeing it between his lips and feeling relieved.

Good. He has the green one. He should stay comfortable.

But when I returned, the pacifier had disappeared.

I’d already searched beneath the couch, around the playpen, and almost everywhere else.

Nothing.

And when Theo inevitably woke around two because of his molar, he’d want that particular pacifier.

Without it, he might cry for an hour.

Brandon could wake up.

And another disagreement might follow.

Then I remembered the camera.

I could check the recording.

The living room security camera covered nearly the entire space through its wide-angle lens.



All I needed to do was rewind to seven o’clock, find the moment the pacifier fell, and enlarge the image to see where it landed.

A simple solution.

Nothing more.

That was genuinely all I intended to do.

I dried my hands.

Picked up my phone.

Opened the security application.

Selected Living Room.

Moved the recording back to 7:00 p.m.

And pressed play.

7:00 p.m.

The living room appeared on my screen from an elevated angle.

The wide-angle lens slightly distorted the edges, but everything was visible.

I watched myself hurry out of the frame toward the hallway, almost running.

Brandon remained in his recliner, feet raised, phone in hand, AirPods in his ears.

Theo sat inside the playpen, sucking his green pacifier while holding a stacking cup.



June and Ivy were on the rug, sitting on their bibbas with their hands linked.

Mabel sat on the sofa with Clover resting in her lap.

Bluey played on the television.

7:01 p.m.

Nothing changed.

Everyone remained where I’d left them.

7:02 p.m.

Still nothing.

7:03 p.m.

Theo dropped his stacking cup.

It rolled toward the side of his playpen.

He looked down at it for a moment.

But he didn’t cry.

Instead, he reached for another toy, a soft building block.

7:04 p.m.

Brandon adjusted his position in the recliner.

He rotated his phone sideways, holding it horizontally while his thumbs moved rapidly across the screen.

He appeared to be playing a game.

I enlarged the recording.

Although I couldn’t make out the display,

colorful light flickered across his face.

It resembled the changing images of a video game.

7:05 p.m.

Nothing unusual happened.

7:06 p.m.

Theo removed the green pacifier from his mouth.

He examined it curiously.

Then he tossed it.

The pacifier sailed over the edge of the playpen, bounced against the rug, and rolled beneath the sofa.

There it was.

The missing pacifier.

Under the left side of the couch, close to one of its legs.

I’d searched beneath the right side.

I had finally found it.

That should have been the end of everything.

I could have closed the application, retrieved the pacifier, and gone upstairs to sleep.

I’d accomplished exactly what I wanted.

But for some reason, I kept watching.

7:07 p.m.

Theo began making unhappy little noises.



He wasn’t crying.

Not yet.

He simply whined softly while reaching toward the side of the playpen where his pacifier had disappeared.

Mm. Mm. Mm.

Brandon didn’t raise his head.

But Mabel noticed.

She looked away from the television and placed Clover beside her.

First, she looked toward Theo.

Then toward Brandon.

Then back at her baby brother.

She climbed down from the sofa and walked over to the playpen.

Standing beside it, she peered down at Theo.

“Theo,” she said.

The security camera recorded sound.

It was faint and slightly distorted, but I could understand her words.

“Theo, what’s wrong? Did you lose your binky?”

Theo stretched his little arms toward her.

Mm. Mm.

Mabel searched around the playpen and examined the rug.

She couldn’t see the pacifier hidden beneath the sofa.

Then she turned toward her father.

“Daddy,” she called.

Brandon didn’t respond.

His AirPods remained in place, and his thumbs continued moving across his phone.

“Daddy,” Mabel repeated, a little louder. “Theo lost his binky.”

Still no response.

She walked toward the recliner.

Standing beside Brandon’s arm, she reached out and gently touched him.

“Daddy,” she explained. “Theo lost his binky. He’s sad.”

Brandon removed one AirPod.

But he kept his attention on the phone rather than looking directly at her.

“Go sit down, Mabes,” he said.

“But Theo—”

He put the AirPod back into his ear.

Mabel remained beside him for a moment.

A four-year-old girl in pink unicorn pajamas.

She looked at her father quietly, waiting as though she hoped he might reconsider.

Then she turned away and returned to the playpen.

7:08 p.m.

Theo’s little complaints became louder.

He still wasn’t fully crying, but he was growing increasingly uncomfortable.