I couldn’t bring myself to return to our bedroom or lie beside Brandon.

I stayed on the couch, staring toward the small white dome mounted near the ceiling.

The security camera.

Brandon’s idea.

Something he’d installed to give me peace of mind.

At 5:42, Theo woke again.

I changed his diaper, prepared his bottle, and rocked him in my arms.

At 6:15, the twins woke.

Ivy had wet her bed.

At 6:30, Mabel came downstairs.

“Pancakes?” she asked.

“Pancakes,” I replied.

So I made pancakes.

I watched Mabel eat hers.

She carefully cut each pancake into neat little squares, making sure the syrup didn’t touch her strawberries.

“Mabel,” I said.

“Yeah?”

“Last night,” I began. “When Mommy was in the shower.”

She stopped eating.

Then she looked at me with unusual care.



“Were you good?” I asked.

Her eyes moved toward the hallway.

Toward the bedroom where Brandon was still sleeping.

Then she looked back at me.

“Yes,” she answered quietly. “We were good.”

“Did anything happen?”

Mabel lowered her gaze toward her breakfast.

“June bumped her head,” she explained. “I did the peas.”

“You did?”

“Like you do,” Mabel said. “In the freezer door. I had to stand on my tiptoes.”

“And Theo?”

“He lost his binky,” she continued. “I sang him your song. And I got his diaper. But I couldn’t reach.”

She raised her eyes toward mine.

“Did Daddy tell you we were good?” she asked.

I looked at my daughter.

Four years old.

Still wearing her pink unicorn pajamas.

A little syrup on her chin.

Waiting for my answer.



Mabel’s expression fell.

“But I saw,” I added.

She looked up.

“I saw everything,” I explained. “On the camera. I saw you sing to Theo. I saw you get the peas for June. I saw you get the diaper.”

Her eyes widened.

“You saw?”

“I saw,” I assured her. “You were so good, Mabel. You were the best big sister in the whole world.”

But she didn’t smile.

Instead, she studied my face for a long moment.

“Then why was Daddy mad?” she whispered.

I couldn’t answer.

At least, not in a way a four-year-old could understand.

Brandon came downstairs at seven.

He’d already showered.

Twenty-five uninterrupted minutes, with the bathroom door closed and music playing.

He entered the kitchen dressed for work and kissed each child on the top of the head.



Then he took a pancake from Mabel’s plate.

“Morning,” he said to me.

His voice sounded distant.

He was apparently still upset about the previous evening.

“Brandon,” I said. “Before you go. I need you to watch something.”

He turned toward me.

“I’m going to be late.”

“It’s twenty minutes,” I replied.

He stared at me.

“You’ve got to be kidding,” he said.

“Twenty minutes,” I repeated. “You can spare twenty minutes.”

Then I handed him my phone.

The security application was already open.

I’d positioned the recording at the exact moment I wanted him to see.

Living Room — Tuesday — 7:00 PM.

Brandon looked down at the phone.

Then he looked at me.

Something shifted in his expression.

It wasn’t anger.

It was an emotion I’d never seen so clearly on his face before.



Fear.

“Erin,” he said.

“Watch it,” I replied.

“I don’t need to—”

“Watch it,” I repeated.

I’d never spoken to him in that tone.

Not once in seven years.

It was the voice I used when I worked at the children’s hospital, particularly with parents who weren’t following their children’s prescribed exercises at home.

The voice that made it clear I wasn’t making a suggestion.

Brandon sat down at the kitchen table.

And began watching.

I took the children into the living room and turned on Bluey.

I settled Theo into his playpen with his green pacifier, then sat beside Mabel on the couch.

From the kitchen, I could hear the recording.

The voices sounded faint and slightly distorted.

Daddy, Theo lost his binky.

Go sit down, Mabes.

You are my sunshine. My only sunshine.

Daddy! June hit her head!

She’s fine. Kids bump their heads.

Mommy will change you. When she’s done. I put your diaper right here. So she doesn’t have to get it.

Daddy, are you going to tell Mommy we were good?

When Mommy comes back, we have to be extra good. So you don’t get mad at her.

Then everything became quiet.

Brandon remained in the kitchen.

He didn’t come out for a long time.

Normally, he left for work at 7:45.

But at 8:15, he was still sitting at the table.

I finally went to check on him.

He held my phone in both hands.

The recording was paused on its final image.

Mabel sitting on the rug.

Her small hands folded neatly in her lap.

Her body perfectly still.