With love,

Grandma Vance.

A cold, burning nausea rose in my throat.

“Perhaps now you’ve earned it.”

She couldn’t even give an eight-year-old child a belated birthday gift without conditioning it on his total surrender. She still demanded he acknowledge that he had been at fault, that his exclusion had been justified, and that her gift was an act of royal benevolence.

The basement door swung open, and Evan’s sneakers squeaked against the kitchen linoleum. “Dad? Where are the extra controllers?”

He paused at the threshold of the garage, his eyes landing on the red box on my workbench.

His expression froze.

The excitement that had filled his eyes all afternoon vanished, replaced by that cautious, guarded stillness that broke my heart every time I saw it.

“Is that…” Evan began, his voice dropping. “Is that from Grandma?”

I looked at Claire, who had stepped into the doorway behind him. Her jaw was set tight, but she gave me a nearly imperceptible nod.

“Yeah, buddy,” I said gently. “It came in the mail.”

Chapter 7

Evan walked slowly toward the workbench. He didn’t rush toward it greedily the way Oliver had. He stopped two feet away, hands clasped in front of him, staring at the red lid.

“Is she… is she still mad at me?” he asked.

“You didn’t do anything wrong, Evan,” I said firmly, dropping to one knee so my eyes were level with his. “I’ve told you that twenty times, and it will always be true. You did nothing wrong.”

Evan extended a finger, lightly brushing the heavy cardstock note. He read the words in silence.

“She said I’ve earned it now,” he whispered. A faint, fragile flicker of hope crossed his features. “Maybe… maybe she isn’t angry anymore. Can I see it?”

I didn’t have the heart to rip it away from him right then, not while his friends were downstairs laughing.

“Sure, buddy. Let’s take a look.”

I lifted the lid. Resting inside was the sleek smartwatch, identical to the ones from Christmas Eve, its black glass face gleaming under the fluorescent shop lights.

Evan picked it up. He held it as though it were blown glass. “It’s really cool.”

“It is cool,” I said. “Tell you what: go finish your game with Liam and Carter. We’ll charge it up and go through the manual together later tonight, okay?”

Evan nodded, handed the watch back to me, and gave me a brief, tight hug. “Thanks, Dad.”

He took off running back into the house.

Claire waited until the basement door clicked shut before turning to me. “You’re not letting him keep that.”

“Of course not,” I said. “Look at the card, Claire. It’s poison. But I wasn’t going to crush him in the middle of his party.”

“So what do we do?”

“We wait until he’s asleep. Tomorrow I’ll tell him the watch had a hardware defect, and we’ll take him to the Apple Store to pick out a brand-new one ourselves—no strings attached.”

“Fine,” Claire said. “Get that thing out of my sight.”

By nine that evening, quiet had finally settled over the house. Evan was sound asleep, thoroughly worn out from cake and gaming.

I took the watch into my office, snapped it onto the magnetic charging puck on my desk, and powered it on. The display woke up with the crisp white logo.

I expected the standard out-of-the-box setup prompt: “Hello. Swipe up to configure.”

It never appeared.

Instead, the screen bypassed setup entirely, booting directly to a customized home face displaying the current time, battery percentage, and local weather.

My fingers went completely still.

A brand-new watch from Miller & Cole should have been unconfigured and sealed in factory plastic, waiting to be paired to a parent’s phone.

The packaging had been tampered with. The factory seal on the inner sleeve had been sliced cleanly with a razor and smoothed back down.

I swiped down from the top edge of the display.

I opened the Settings menu.

I scrolled down to Apple ID & Family Sharing.

There, displayed in clear gray lettering beneath the active profile icon, was an email address I had seen a thousand times:

Evelyn.Vance48@icloud.com

My blood turned to slush.

I dug deeper into the settings.

Family Sharing: ACTIVE.

Screen Time Management: MANAGED BY EVELYN VANCE.

Location Services: ALWAYS ALLOW.

Share My Location: ACTIVELY SHARING WITH EVELYN VANCE (PARENT/ORGANIZER).

Ambient Noise Monitoring Permissions: ENABLED.

I sat in the darkened office, the pale blue glow of the watch screen reflecting in my lenses, my heart hammering against my ribs like a caged bird.

Evelyn hadn’t sent an olive branch.

She had dispatched a digital surveillance wiretap.

Had Evan strapped that watch to his wrist the following morning and walked out the door, my mother would have had real-time, 24/7 GPS tracking of every single place my son went: his school, his friends’ houses, the park, his pediatrician’s office.