Then she picked up the fourth box. Walking straight past Evan without slowing her stride, she set it down before Claire, then placed the fifth box directly in front of me.
“For Jake and Claire,” she said casually, turning to head back toward the head of the table. “Now everyone has one. We’ll take a family photo by the fireplace showing all our wrists.”
The temperature in the room felt as if it had plummeted ten degrees.
Evan sat between Claire and me. His hands were still tucked beneath his thighs. He looked at the box in front of Claire, then at the box in front of me, and finally down at the bare wooden space between his fork and his water glass.
Claire didn’t touch her box. I didn’t touch mine.
“Mom,” I said, my voice level, even though my chest felt like an engine revving without oil. “You missed Evan.”
Evelyn paused, her hand resting on the back of her chair. She didn’t turn around immediately. She took her napkin, folded it into a neat triangle, and laid it beside her crystal water glass.
When she finally turned, she wore that rehearsed, patronizing smile.
“Oh, not for him,” she said.
She said it clearly. Not in a whisper. Not offhandedly. She said it into the dead silence of the room, loud enough that even my father’s carving knife froze against the bone.
“What did you say?” I asked.
Evelyn let out that airy, delicate laugh I had heard every time she told me my grades weren’t quite good enough or that my childhood art projects were “a bit too messy for the fridge.”
“He hasn’t earned it, Jake. Maybe next year, once he learns some manners.”
The grandfather clock in the foyer ticked three times. It sounded like an axe striking timber.
Evan’s head sank lower. His little chin gave one violent tremble before he pressed his lips hard against his teeth. He squeezed his eyes shut for a second, then raised his head, cheeks flushed crimson, offering a tight, pained smile.
“It’s okay, Dad,” Evan whispered. “I don’t even like watches.”
The sound of his voice—trying so hard to shield the adults from the ugliness hanging over the room—nearly shattered my self-control.
Claire reached under the table. Her fingers dug into my knee with painful force. She was trembling.
“What manners are you talking about, Mom?” I asked. My voice wasn’t raised, but its tone vibrated through the crystal stemware.
Evelyn sighed—an exaggerated, theatrical sigh designed to broadcast to everyone how terribly she suffered under my insolence. “Jake, please don’t start your annual routine. It’s Christmas Eve. Must you always make everything about yourself?”
“I’m asking about my son,” I said. “He walked through the front door, took off his shoes, said ‘Merry Christmas, Grandma,’ and hung up his coat. What bad behavior are you punishing an eight-year-old child for on Christmas Eve?”
“He barely looked at me when he said hello,” Evelyn snapped, her mask slipping for an instant to reveal the sharp, bitter glare beneath. “He mumbled. He went straight to the corner with that silly little notepad and scribbled instead of properly greeting his aunt and uncle. I don’t tolerate poor conduct. There are standards in this house.”
She turned her gaze to Oliver, who was currently tapping his new watch against his water glass to see if it would ring.
“Perhaps he could take a cue from his cousin,” Evelyn said with dripping sweetness. “Such a polite, confident young man. Some boys simply carry themselves with dignity.”
Megan snickered into her wine glass. “Mom’s right, Jake. You let Evan live in his own head too much. He’s antisocial. You should have put him in karate or something, like we did with Ollie.”
My father looked down at the floor. Slowly, he set the carving knife on the silver platter, wiped his hands on a kitchen towel, and walked wordlessly into the pantry. He didn’t look at Evan. He didn’t look at me. He simply retreated.
“Eat your dinner, everyone,” Evelyn said, sitting down and smoothing her velvet skirt. “Let’s not let the ham get cold over Jake’s theatrics.”
Evan didn’t touch his food. He sat there staring at his plate, blinking rapidly to hold back the tears that dampened the collar of his shirt. His knuckles were white against his knees.
Chapter 3
I remained seated. Not out of fear, but because thirty-six years under Evelyn Vance’s thumb had taught me that she never stopped after the first cut. She always wanted to see if she could draw arterial blood.
Five minutes passed in suffocating silence, broken only by Todd chewing his ham and Megan rambling about Oliver’s winter league schedule.
Then Evelyn stood up again.
Popular Posts
→- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
Recently Viewed
Stories you read recently will appear here.



