I read it out loud. Derek’s head snapped up. “What file?” he asked.
I flipped the notebook to its very last page. A title was written across the top in Donna’s neat script: “Reasons Why Megan Shouldn’t Be Alone With the Babies.” And beneath that heading, the list had already begun. Donna wasn’t just trying to be right about the formula. She wanted to convince everyone that I couldn’t be trusted with my own children. The notebook in my hands made that possibility impossible to ignore.
The final pages were filled with accusations disguised as observations. I had cried during a late-night feeding. I had forgotten to reply to a text for four hours. I had let dishes pile up in the sink. I had refused to let Donna wake Sadie up to show me how to feed her. There were notes about my scar hurting, laundry piling up, and a time I asked Rachel to bring dinner because I didn’t have the energy to cook.
All of it was true in the most superficial sense. None of it made me unfit. Yet stripped of context and reorganized with cold certainty, ordinary postpartum fatigue had been twisted into a list of suspicious behaviors. “Why would she write this?” I asked Derek.
He rubbed his palms together. “She thought you weren’t coping.”
“Did you think I wasn’t coping?”
“I knew you were tired.”
“Being tired doesn’t mean being dangerous.”
“I know that now.”
“It’s a little late to learn it.”
Rachel read the page once and took a deep breath. “We’re putting this somewhere safe. Then we’re finding out who sent those texts.”
I texted the unknown number asking if we could talk. The reply came almost immediately: “My name is Elaine. I’m Donna’s younger sister. She told the family you were unstable. I couldn’t sit back after hearing about Molly.”
Elaine. I had met her at our wedding and twice at Thanksgiving. She was quiet and kind, with the same blue eyes as Donna, but without her knack for turning a compliment into a criticism. Donna considered her overly sensitive. Now I wondered if that was simply Donna’s word for someone who refused to praise her.
Elaine called me that afternoon. She explained that Donna had invited several family members to a video call the night before. Officially, it was to discuss how they could help our family with the twins. Instead, Donna spent forty minutes painting herself as the only responsible adult in the house. She told stories about my crying, my exhaustion, and my insistence on following the pediatrician’s orders as if they were signs of irrationality. “She said you were starving the girls,” Elaine told me. “She said she’d soon have proof that your feeding choices were causing their issues. Megan… she almost sounded excited.”
Chapter 9
I gripped the phone tight. “Did Derek join the call?”
“No. She said he was too upset to stand up to you.”
Derek was sitting next to me on Rachel’s couch. He heard every word. For the first time, he looked offended on my behalf rather than making excuses for his mother. Elaine continued: “She sent an email beforehand. I saved it. I can forward it to you.”
The email arrived a few minutes later. Subject: CONCERNS ABOUT THE GIRLS. In it, Donna described my supposed emotional instability and claimed she had been quietly documenting the twins’ health. She implied the family might need to arrange more intensive care if I “continued to be stubborn.” In one paragraph, she mentioned consulting a lawyer about grandparents’ options if the babies’ health was at risk.
I read until my vision blurred. She had laid the groundwork for a story where she was the savior and I was the threat. The medical emergency she caused would have been devastating enough on its own. The possibility that she intended to use a feeding experiment to discredit me made her monstrous in a far more insidious, deliberate way.
“Did she ask you to sign anything?” Rachel asked Elaine.
“Not yet. She said she’d circulate a statement if people agreed.”
“Send me every message you have,” I said. “And please, don’t tell her we spoke until you’re ready.”
Elaine agreed. She also told me Donna had once referred to our house as “the house Derek bought for the girls.” Derek and I had worked hard to pay for it. My name was on the deed. Somehow, in Donna’s version of our lives, I had become a temporary guest in my own family.
Popular Posts
→- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
Recently Viewed
Stories you read recently will appear here.



