She also had a remarkable ability to make her own preferences sound like everybody else’s best interests.

Three Sundays before Christmas, we were eating dinner at her house when she made the offer.

“Why don’t you bring the children here Christmas Eve?” she said, passing a bowl of green beans.

I looked up.

“Are you sure?”

“Of course. They’ll sleep upstairs, and we’ll all have Christmas morning together.”

“My shift doesn’t end until three.”

“Then come over afterward. You can sleep on the couch.”

I hesitated.

“What about Lauren and the boys?”

My younger sister, Lauren, was thirty-two.

She and her husband, Ben Carter, had two sons, ages six and four.

They were planning to spend Christmas morning at Mom’s house too.

Mom waved a hand.

“The more, the merrier. That’s what Christmas is supposed to be.”

“Mom, I don’t want you overwhelmed.”

She laughed.

“Rebecca, I’ve raised two girls. I think I can manage four grandchildren for one night.”

My father, Harold, looked up from his dinner.

“Your mother enjoys having everybody around.”

I watched her smile.

Then I asked the question I wish I’d asked more carefully.

“So I can definitely count on you?”

Mom reached across the table and touched my wrist.

“Sweetheart, who else would you count on?”

Everybody laughed.

I smiled too.

But something about those words stayed with me.

Who else would you count on?

My mother had a habit of turning help into a reminder that you needed her.

Even so, I ignored the uncomfortable feeling.

It was Christmas.

My children deserved a holiday with their grandparents.

And I wanted to believe she meant every word.

Chapter 2: The House With Green Shutters

My parents lived in a white two-story house on Willow Lane.

It had dark green shutters, a broad front porch, and a wooden swing that made a small squeaking sound whenever the wind moved it.

The backyard held an enormous maple tree.

Inside, the house smelled of cinnamon in December and fresh laundry almost every day of the year.

I’d known that house since childhood.

But it wasn’t actually my childhood home.

It had belonged to my grandmother, Eleanor Price.

My mother’s mother.

Grandma Eleanor was the one person in my family who seemed to recognize when I was carrying more than I admitted.

She had a way of watching me across the kitchen table and asking, “Are you doing okay, honey?” without accepting my usual automatic answer.

She’d lived in that house for more than forty years.

She’d planted the maple tree.

Hung the porch swing.

And sewn two little red Christmas stockings when my children were babies.

One had a white M.

The other had a white L.

Every December, she insisted on putting an orange into the toe of each stocking.

“It’s how my mother did it,” she’d explain.

“Why an orange?” Mason once asked.

“Because when I was little, getting an orange in winter was a treat.”

Mason had considered that.

“Can we also have candy?”

Grandma laughed.

“Absolutely.”

Those stockings were among my most treasured possessions.

A week before Christmas, I’d taken them to Mom’s house, along with stocking fillers I’d purchased myself.

Candy canes.

A paperback adventure novel for Mason.

Glitter pens for Lily.

And two oranges.

I wanted the morning to feel familiar.

Safe.

Full of the things children remember.

There was another reason the house mattered to me, but almost nobody in my family understood it.

Six years earlier, when Grandma Eleanor’s estate was settled, she’d left that house to me.

Not to Mom.

Not to Lauren.

To me.

The reason went back to the final two years of her life.

Her mobility had gradually declined, and she needed help with appointments, groceries, medications, and everyday household tasks.

I came almost every day.

Sometimes I brought Mason.

Sometimes I carried baby Lily inside in her car seat.

On Sunday evenings, I’d help Grandma wash and style her hair.

She’d sit in her favorite chair, complain that I was brushing too hard, and then ask me to brush a little longer.

Mom visited during major holidays and occasionally on weekends.

Lauren came by a handful of times.

I’m not saying that to make either of them look bad.

It’s simply what happened.

I was the one who knew Grandma’s pharmacy number.

I was the one who remembered which groceries she liked.

I was the one who sat beside her when she was tired and listened to stories she’d already told me three times.

A few months before she passed away, she asked me to bring her a pen and a notebook.

We sat together at her kitchen table.

She looked out the window toward the maple tree.

“Rebecca, you’ve been here an awful lot.”

“You’re stuck with me, Grandma.”

She smiled.