Sarah’s breath caught. Her hand left her belly and reached toward the air, her pulse hammering visibly against the pale skin of her throat. “Eleanor, please. Dr. Henderson gave me that yesterday afternoon. It’s the high-resolution scan. Julian hasn’t even seen it yet.”

“An ultrasound,” Eleanor said, turning the slip toward the gray light. “A gray smudge of tissue and water. You treat it like an oil painting. You leave it about as if to mark your territory, reminding me that your common blood has managed to graft itself onto my family’s roots.”

“It’s Richard’s grandchild,” Sarah whispered, taking the last three stairs with careful, hurried steps until she stood on the mezzanine landing, ten feet from the older woman. “It’s Julian’s daughter. Give it to me, Eleanor. Please.”

“Richard is buried beneath six feet of granite in Saint Jude’s churchyard,” Eleanor said, her voice dropping into a register that didn’t carry down to the maids, though Arthur, stationed at the base of the stairs, caught every syllable. “He was an old man who lost his wits before he died. If he had possessed an ounce of his former intellect, he would have rewritten his trust before you smiled your way into my stepson’s bed.”

“Julian loves me,” Sarah said, her voice shaking now, the exhaustion of thirty-two weeks of hostility finally fracturing her composure. “And I love him. We never asked for your money. We never wanted this house.”

“Then you should have stayed in your two-bedroom rental in Dorchester,” Eleanor spat, the high-society veneer cracking wide open to reveal the raw, gutter hatred beneath. “You should have stayed where nobody would ever confuse you for a Vance.”

Sarah stepped forward, her hand outstretched, her eyes fixed entirely upon the curled photograph. “Just give it back.”

Eleanor smiled. It was not the tight, practiced grimace she wore for the benefit of the symphony board or the charity galas. It was the naked, ravenous grin of a creature that had finally found the marrow.

She brought her thumbs together.

Skrrrrtch.

The sound was shockingly loud in the cavernous hall. The photographic paper, reinforced by its laminated backing, tore with a sharp, fibrous scream.

Mrs. Gable, fifty feet below, squeezed her eyes shut and dropped her chin toward her breastbone, her shoulders hitching. The two young maids froze, their pumice stones poised in the air like dead weights.

“Oops,” Eleanor whispered.

She parted her fingers. The two jagged halves fluttered into the draft of the atrium, turning over and over like wounded moths as they began their slow descent toward the checkerboard marble of the foyer.

Sarah cried out—a raw, maternal sound ripped straight from her chest. Forgetting her balance, forgetting the sheer drop, forgetting the low ironwork railing, she lunged forward toward the lip of the landing, her hands grasping wildly at empty air.

Eleanor did not hesitate.

Her movements were neither panicked nor clumsy. With a cold, mechanical economy, she planted her back foot against the floor, raised both palms flat against Sarah’s shoulder blades, and shoved.

“You clumsy little bitch,” Eleanor hissed.

The physics were brutal and instantaneous. Sarah’s center of gravity was already displaced by the weight of her child. Her soft-soled shoes found no purchase on the wax-rubbed floor. Her shins struck the low iron rail, her body tipped like a felling timber, and her feet left the stone.

She didn’t scream a second time; the breath was knocked from her lungs as her back cleared the balustrade. The twenty-foot drop to the marble floor yawned beneath her, unforgiving, cold, and final.

Eleanor stood upright, smoothing her sleeves with two sharp jerks of her wrists. She drew in a deep, lung-filling breath of the damp sea air, already framing the narrative in her mind: She reached for the picture. She leaned too far. I tried to grab her hem, but my hands were slick with hand cream. It was horrible, officer. Simply horrible.

She leaned over to look down at the butcher’s bill.

She expected the wet, heavy crack of bone against stone. She expected the high-pitched shriek of the maids. She expected the blood.

She did not expect Arthur Finch.

Arthur had not shouted. He had not gasped. For forty-two years, his reflexes had been honed by catching falling crystal decanters before they kissed mahogany, by anticipating the missteps of drunk shipping tycoons and frail old men. But what moved him now was something far older than domestic service: an ironclad vow made to a dying man in a darkened bedroom five years prior.

As Sarah cleared the rail, Arthur abandoned every vestige of elderly decorum.