Behind me, Elena was sobbing. “I fed him. I swear. I never wanted him dead.”

I looked over my shoulder. She was curled against the wall, crying into both hands. For the first time in my life, I did not see my sister. I saw the woman who had helped Sarah hang missing posters while my son was hidden beneath her house. The woman who had hugged my daughter while Leo was trapped in darkness. The woman who had poured tea three feet above him.

My grief disappeared, and something colder took its place. I looked back into the hole. “Leo, hold on.”

His fingers tightened around mine. “I knew you’d come.”

My heart cracked open. “I’m here now.”

As my son clung to me from beneath that flawless floor, I finally understood the truth. Leo had never disappeared. Someone had taken him. Someone had hidden him. Someone I loved—and she was sitting only a few feet away, begging me not to discover why.

Chapter 2

I called 911 with one hand while keeping the other wrapped around Leo’s wrist. The dispatcher kept asking questions: Was he conscious? Was he injured? Was the person responsible still inside the house?

I looked at Elena. “Yes.”

Her head snapped up. “David—”

“Don’t move.”

She flinched. I had never spoken to my sister that way, and I had also never known my sister could steal a child.

Maya crouched beside me. “Leo?”

A weak sound came from below. “Maya?”

She covered her mouth. “It’s me.”

I heard something that sounded almost like a laugh. “You got bigger.”

Maya started sobbing. I wanted to reach through the hole and pull him out immediately, but I could see enough now to know the space below wasn’t simple. There was concrete beneath the boards—a narrow cavity had been built between the original foundation and a raised floor. Someone had created it intentionally. That realization made me sick.

“Leo, can you move?”

“My leg hurts.”

“Okay. Don’t try.”

Sirens reached us minutes later. Elena stood, and I pointed at her. “Sit down.”

“I can explain.”

“You can explain to the police.”

Her face changed. “Please don’t let them take me before I tell you.”

I almost laughed. “My son has been missing for fourteen months.”

“I know.”

“You watched us bury an empty box at the memorial.”

“I know.”

“You watched Sarah nearly die from grief.”

“I know.”

I stood. “Then there is nothing you can tell me that I want to hear.”

Police entered first, followed by firefighters and paramedics. The living room filled with people, and the perfect house finally looked like what it was: a crime scene. A firefighter widened the opening carefully. One officer pulled Maya away while I stayed close enough for Leo to hear me.

“I’m right here, buddy.”

“Don’t leave.”

“I won’t.”

When they finally lifted him out, I nearly collapsed. He weighed almost nothing. His hair had grown unevenly down his neck, his clothes were too small, and his face was pale and hollow. There were bruises on his knees, and his lips were cracked. But his eyes—his eyes were still Leo’s.

He looked straight at me. “Dad.”

I reached for him, but a paramedic blocked me. “Let us stabilize him.”

“He’s my son.”

“I know.”

Leo panicked. “No! Dad!”

I pushed past. “I’m here.”

He grabbed my shirt. “Don’t let her put me back.”

Every officer in the room heard him. So did Elena. Her face went white. An officer stepped toward her. “Elena Vance, put your hands behind your back.”

She started crying. “No, wait.”

“You are being detained.”

“David!”

I didn’t look at her.

“David, there’s more!”

That got my attention. As the officer tightened the cuffs, I asked, “What does that mean?”

Elena shook her head rapidly. “Not here.”

My stomach dropped. “What did you do?”

“I wasn’t the only one.”

The room went still. An officer immediately pulled her toward the front door. “Who else?” I demanded.

Elena pressed her lips together.

“Tell me!”

She looked straight into my eyes. “Ask your father.”

I felt the floor tilt. My father, Robert Vance—the man whose property Leo had disappeared from, the man who had financed search parties, the man who had publicly offered a hundred-thousand-dollar reward, and the man who still called me every Sunday asking whether detectives had developed new leads.

“No.”

Elena lowered her head. That was all. Police took her outside, and I followed Leo to the ambulance. Maya climbed in beside me after an officer confirmed she could come.

Sarah was two hours away. I called her, and she answered on the first ring.

“David?” Her voice was tired.

I couldn’t speak.

“What happened?”