Three hours later, after Evan had finally fallen asleep in his room with his bedside lamp left on, my phone lit up on the kitchen island.

Chapter 4

A text message from Evelyn:

“You completely embarrassed yourself tonight. Todd and Megan were disgusted by your behavior. Your father is heartbroken. You owe me $120 for the three meals I prepared for you. I expect payment via Venmo by tomorrow morning and an apology before you ever set foot in this house again.”

I stared at the screen in the dark kitchen.

A low, dry sound escaped my throat. A laugh.

Claire came down the stairs wrapped in her flannel bathrobe, her face pale in the moonlight streaming through the kitchen window. “Jake? What’s going on?”

I held up the phone. “She wants forty dollars a plate.”

Claire didn’t laugh. She walked over to the kitchen trash can, opened it, and pulled an empty cardboard box out of the recycling bin. She set it on the countertop; her eyes were completely dry and ice-cold now.

“Tomorrow,” Claire said, “we change the locks. And we never, ever go back.”

“I’m with you,” I whispered.

The next morning around seven o’clock, I crept into Evan’s bedroom to check on him.

He was sprawled across his bed, fast asleep, still wearing his dark blue shirt. He had fallen asleep with his colored pencils scattered across the comforter.

On his desk lay his sketchbook, open to the last page.

I walked over, my stocking feet silent on the carpet, and looked down.

He had drawn a massive, gold-framed chair that looked like a throne. Sitting on the throne was a woman with bright yellow hair and a diamond crown. Surrounding her, people were holding large red boxes tied with shiny bows, their mouths stretched into wide, exaggerated smiles.

In the far bottom corner of the paper, separated from the rest of the room by a thick black line he had scribbled over and over until the paper tore, stood a tiny stick-figure boy with empty hands.

Above the boy’s head, written in crooked, uneven pencil letters, were six words:

Maybe I’ll be good enough next year.

I stood in the morning light staring at that piece of paper until my vision blurred and the last shred of sentimentality I felt for the woman who raised me burned to ash.

I was sitting at the kitchen table with a mug of black coffee when my phone buzzed. Aunt Brenda, my mother’s older sister from Ohio, was calling. Brenda hadn’t called me directly since my college graduation twelve years ago.

“Jake,” Brenda said without saying hello. Her voice was already trembling with that particular brand of self-righteous outrage reserved for older relatives who have only heard one side of the story. “I just spent forty-five minutes on the phone with your mother. She is in tears. She told me you threw a plate across the dining table on Christmas Eve and scared your nephew to death.”

I took a slow sip of coffee. “Brenda, did she mention why I got up from the table?”

“She said Evan threw a tantrum because Oliver got a gift from his grandmother and you encouraged him! She said you demanded she buy him an expensive computer right then and there!”

“Brenda,” I said, keeping my voice completely calm. “Did my mother tell you she bought identical watches for every adult and child in the room, handed them out one by one, and skipped Evan while telling everyone at the table he didn’t deserve one because he had bad manners?”

Silence on the other end of the line. A brief, fleeting rustle.

“Well,” Brenda stammered, “she… she said Evan was very disrespectful when he arrived. You know how much value your mother places on proper etiquette, Jake. You’ve always been so overly sensitive about these things. Ever since you were a boy, you’ve always misunderstood…”

“Brenda,” I interrupted her. “Don’t call this number again.”

I hung up and blocked her immediately.

Within two hours, two more cousins had reached out. Megan had posted a photo of Oliver on Facebook wearing his watch and holding his iPad, captioned: “Surrounded by love and true family harmony. Some people choose bitterness; we choose joy and grace! #Blessed #FamilyFirst #MannersMatter.”

The comments underneath read like an echo chamber of suburban aunts and family friends praising Evelyn for being such an extraordinary, long-suffering matriarch.

“You are such an angel, Evelyn!”

“Raising boys is hard, but bad manners should never be rewarded!”

“Family drama is so sad, but boundaries are important!”

Claire stood behind me reading the screen while braiding her hair. “Delete the app, Jake. Stop looking at it.”

“I’m not hurt,” I said, and to my surprise, it was the absolute truth. “I’m documenting everything.”