Brooke continued the introductions rapidly, barely pausing for proper acknowledgments—her parents, Richard and Elaine Thompson; her sister Tiffany and brother-in-law, Patrick; three senior partners from Bradley’s firm and their wives; two couples introduced as dear friends; and finally a young woman named Alexa, whom Brooke described as her absolute lifesaver of an assistant.

Twenty-two people in total, just as Brooke had declared, now stood in my small front yard, designer luggage at their feet, expectation written across their faces.

“Well,” I said brightly, “shall we go inside? I’ve prepared a light welcome refreshment.”

I led the procession through my front door, listening to the murmurs and whispers behind me. The main living area, while charming with its exposed beams and panoramic ocean views, was clearly not designed for twenty-two people. My carefully arranged furniture could comfortably seat perhaps eight.

“It’s so cozy,” Elaine Thompson remarked, the word dripping with barely concealed disdain. “Where should we put our bags?”

“Where are the guest suites?” one of the senior partners’ wives added, scanning the space with a faint frown.

“Charming,” another murmured in the tone of someone describing a child’s school project.

“I’ve made some special arrangements,” I assured them, gesturing toward the dining table, where I’d set out a pitcher of fresh lemonade and a plate of cookies. “But first, please help yourselves to refreshments while I explain the accommodations.”

They clustered awkwardly around the table, some perching on the limited seating, others standing as I poured lemonade into the mismatched collection of glasses I had deliberately selected from the kitchen cabinets.

“As you can see,” I began pleasantly, “my cottage is rather intimate. With only two bedrooms, I knew I wouldn’t be able to accommodate everyone comfortably here.”

Brooke’s head snapped up, her expression sharpening.

“But I told you—”

“So,” I continued smoothly, “I’ve arranged alternative accommodations for most of you at various locations around town.”

A confused murmur rippled through the group. Brooke’s face flushed with the first signs of alarm.

“Dorothy, that wasn’t necessary,” she said tersely. “We discussed this. Everyone was prepared to make do here.”

“I couldn’t possibly allow that,” I replied, my voice warm with concern. “Not when there are so many lovely options nearby. Though I should mention, this being the start of the spring season, availability was somewhat limited on such short notice.”

I retrieved a stack of envelopes from a side table and began distributing them.

“I’ve prepared individual accommodation details for each of you.”

Diana Westfield opened her envelope first, her expression shifting from confusion to dismay.

“The Harborview Motel. On Route 6.”

“It’s the only place that had a vacancy for tonight,” I explained apologetically. “The reviews mentioned that the traffic noise tapers off around midnight and the musty smell is only noticeable in the bathroom.”

A couple of the senior partners shifted uncomfortably.

Jonathan Westfield’s envelope contained a reservation for the Seabreeze Inn, a modest bed-and-breakfast nearly five miles away.

“They only had one room available,” I told him. “So Diana will need to take the motel. I do hope that’s not too inconvenient.”

As each envelope was opened, the reactions grew increasingly strained. The Thompson parents were assigned to separate establishments in neighboring towns. Tiffany and Patrick discovered they would be staying at a campground, with a rental tent already secured for them.

“The manager assured me the raccoon problem has been largely resolved,” I added helpfully.

One of Bradley’s senior partners unfolded his slip of paper and read aloud.

“A room above the… bait shop?”

He looked up, aghast.

“The proprietor described it as ‘rustic but functional,’” I said. “Very authentic to the local fishing culture.”

“There must be some mistake,” Bradley said, looking increasingly uncomfortable. “Surely there are better options in the area.”

“On a spring weekend with less than twenty-four hours’ notice?” I shook my head sadly. “I called everywhere within thirty miles. These were the only vacancies available. The Cape gets quite busy this time of year, with the whale-watching season beginning.”

Brooke had turned an interesting shade of pink.

“This is unacceptable,” she hissed at me, dropping all pretense of politeness. “The Westfields cannot stay at a roadside motel. Do you have any idea how important they are?”

“I’m sure they’re lovely people regardless of where they sleep,” I replied innocently.

“That’s not what I—”

She stopped herself, visibly struggling to maintain composure in front of her guests.

“What about here? Surely some of us can stay here.”

“Oh, of course,” I agreed readily. “I’ve prepared my guest room for you and Bradley, and the Thompson parents can have my room. I’ll take the sofa. The rest, I’m afraid, will need to use the accommodations I’ve arranged.”

Diana Westfield cleared her throat delicately.

“Perhaps we should consider returning to Boston,” she suggested to her husband. “It’s only a two-hour drive, after all.”