I tried to remember the last time Rory had commented on a picture of Sadie. I scrolled back through his page. A month. Two months. Six.

Nothing. Not a single comment. Not on her homecoming photo in September. Not on her volleyball trophy in November. Not on the picture I posted for her seventeenth birthday in January.

He had hearted a few of them. That was all. A little red heart, no words.

Then I heard Sadie’s door.

Across the hall. I had thought she was asleep. Her light had been off for an hour. But I heard her door open, heard her cross into the bathroom, heard the water run.

Then her door closed again, very softly, the way you close a door when you don’t want anyone to know you were awake.

She had seen it.

Of course she had. She’s seventeen. Her phone is her whole world. She follows Tasha. She follows Madison. She follows her dad.

She had seen her stepsister in a six-hundred-dollar dress. And she had seen her father’s comment underneath.

Beautiful girl. So proud.

I got up and stood outside her door in the dark hallway, one hand on the doorknob.

I could hear her breathing on the other side. Not crying. Just breathing, slow and careful, the way you breathe when you’re trying very hard not to cry.

I didn’t open the door.

I went back to bed and lay there staring at the ceiling until two in the morning.

I did not call him.

I want that understood. At two in the morning I held my phone with his name pulled up and my thumb hovering over the call button. I could have woken him and said everything I’d been holding in for eleven years.

I didn’t.

I have been divorced from Rory for eleven years, and I know every way that call goes.

If I call angry, he gets defensive. He says I’m always trying to make him the bad guy. He says I don’t understand how hard it is. He says Tasha’s money is Tasha’s money and he doesn’t control what she spends it on.

Then he hangs up. And then he doesn’t call Sadie for two weeks. And Sadie thinks it’s her fault.

If I call calm, he agrees with everything I say. He says he’ll fix it. He says he’ll call Sadie. He says he’s sorry.

Then he doesn’t. And Sadie thinks it’s her fault.

Rory and I married at twenty-two, in the Lutheran church in Howard, where his mother did the hair of every woman in town. Sadie was born when we were twenty-five.

He was a good husband for about five years. He was a welder at a trailer manufacturer in Madison. He was funny. He could fix anything. He used to lift Sadie onto his shoulders at the county fair so she could see the tractor pull.

Then he started staying late at the bar after work. Then he started not coming home. Then, when Sadie was six, I found the messages from Tasha on his phone.

We were divorced eight months later.

He moved to Mitchell and married Tasha two years after that. She had a daughter, Madison, Sadie’s age, six months younger.

He got Sadie every other weekend. He paid child support, six hundred and twelve dollars a month, through the state. The Department of Social Services takes it straight out of his paycheck.

He has never missed a payment. I’ll give him that. Eleven years. Not one.

But he missed everything else.

He missed her first piano recital. He missed most of her volleyball games. He missed her eighth-grade graduation because Madison had a dance competition in Sioux Falls that same day.

He calls on her birthday, most years. He sends a card with a twenty tucked inside.

He takes her every other weekend. Usually. When he isn’t working. When Madison doesn’t have something.

He loves her. I believe that. I always have.

He just loves her from a distance, like she’s a picture on a wall he walks past every day without really seeing.

He was Sadie’s father, not mine to fix.

That’s what I told myself, lying there at two in the morning. It’s what my counselor told me five years ago, when I was still crying about it every week.

You can’t make him be the father she needs, Jodi. You can only be the mother she needs.

And I couldn’t make him pay.

The child support was what the court ordered. Six hundred and twelve dollars a month. A prom dress isn’t in the court order. Neither is showing up.

But I knew who loved her.

I knew one person who had never once missed anything. Not one birthday. Not one concert. Not one volleyball game. Not one Christmas.